Internal Revenue Service (IRS) Appeals Officer Not Impartial

The 10th Circuit Court of Appeals has reversed a decision of the United States Tax Court (Tax Court), and held that an Internal Revnue Service Appeals Officer was not impartial within the meaning of Internal Revenue Code (IRC) § 6330. Cox v. Commissioner, No. 06-9004 (2008), reversing, Cox v. Commissioner, 126 T.C. No.13 (2006). A taxpayer is generally entitled to a collection due process (CDP) hearing before an impartial Appeals Officer before the IRS may levy on his property. If the IRS files a tax lien the taxpayer is entitled to a hearing to contest the tax lien, but only after the tax lien has been filed. In Cox, the taxpayer had received a CDP hearing for the years 2000. In that hearing the Appeals Officer determined that he could not recommend an alternative to a levy since among other things the Coxes hadn’t paid their estimated taxes.

Subequently, the Coxes requested a CDP hearing with respect to the taxes they owed for 2001 and 2002. When the same Appeals Officer was assigned the CDP hearing the Coxes asked the case to be reassigned to a new Appeals Officer since, they argued, the Appeals Officer was not impartial because of his prior involvment. The IRS refused, and ultimately the Coxes appealed to the United States Tax Court. The Tax Court reviewed IRS Treas. Reg. § 301.6330-1(d)(2) which provides that even though an Appeals Officer has had prior involvement with the same taxpayers for a different tax year the Appeals Officer may still conduct the subsequent CDP hearing. The Tax Court upheld the IRS Regulation. On appeal, however, the 10th Circuit reversed. Arguably the 10th Circuit’s decision may be limited to the facts since in Cox the Appeals Officer had reviewed the 2001 and 2002 as part of his decision in the 2000 CDP hearing. In any event the Tax Court is not bound to follow the 10th Circuit’s ruling in cases that are not appealable to the 10th Circuit. Golsen v. Commissioner,54 T.C 742 (1970). It is not, however, unusual for the Tax Court to re-examine its decision where it has been reversed by a Circuit Court of Appeal even though it is not required to do so.

If you have IRS tax problems or California tax problems contact Los Angeles, California State Bar Certified Tax Specialist Dennis Brager.

Contact Information